| Year | American League | | No. | | Year | National League | | No. |
| 1950 | Gus Zernial | Chicago White Sox | 1 | | 1950 | Roy Smalley | Chicago Cubs | |
| 1951 | Ken Wood | St. Louis Browns | | | 1951 | Hank Sauer | Chicago Cubs | |
| 1952 | Walt Dropo | Boston/Detroit | | | 1952 | Eddie Mathews | Boston Braves | |
| 1953 | Eddie Robinson | Philadelphia Athletics | | | 1953 | Steve Bilko | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 1954 | Roy Sievers | Washington Senators | | | 1954 | Wally Post | Cincinnati Reds | 1 |
| 1955 | Gus Zernial | Kansas City Athletics | 2 | | 1955 | Rip Repulski | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 1956 | Hank Bauer | New York Yankees | | | 1956 | Del Ennis | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 1957 | Gus Zernial | Kansas City Athletics | 3 | | 1957 | Wally Post | Cincinnati Reds | 2 |
| 1958 | Roger Maris | Cleveland/Kansas City | | | 1958 | Bill Mazeroski | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 1959 | Gus Triandos | Baltimore Orioles | | | 1959 | Wally Post | Philadelphia Phillies | 3 |
| 1960 | Rocky Colavito | Detroit Tigers | | | 1960 | Frank Thomas | Chicago Cubs | |
| 1961 | Willie Kirkland | Cleveland Indians | 1 | | 1961 | Don Demeter | Los Angeles/Philadelphia | |
| 1962 | Willie Kirkland | Cleveland Indians | 2 | | 1962 | Joe Adcock | Milwaukee Braves | |
| 1963 | Lou Clinton | Boston Red Sox | | | 1963 | Ernie Banks | Chicago Cubs | 1 |
| 1964 | Joe Pepitone | New York Yankees | 1 | | 1964 | Frank Howard | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 1965 | Ken Harrelson | Kansas City Athletics | | | 1965 | Dick Stuart | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 1966 | Joe Pepitone | New York Yankees | 2 | | 1966 | Leo Cardenas | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1967 | Mickey Mantle | New York Yankees | | | 1967 | Clete Boyer | Atlanta Braves | |
| 1968 | Bob Allison | Minnesota Twins | | | 1968 | Ernie Banks | Chicago Cubs | 2 |
| 1969 | Brooks Robinson | Baltimore Orioles | | | 1969 | Ernie Banks | Chicago Cubs | 3 |
| 1970 | Bob Oliver | Kansas City Royals | | | 1970 | Lee May | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1971 | George Scott | Boston Red Sox | 1 | | 1971 | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1972 | George Scott | Milwaukee Brewers | 2 | | 1972 | Dave Kingman | San Francisco Giants | 1 |
| 1973 | Carlton Fisk | Boston Red Sox | | | 1973 | Dave Kingman | San Francisco Giants | 2 |
| 1974 | Bobby Darwin | Minnesota Twins | | | 1974 | Dave Kingman | San Francisco Giants | 3 |
| 1975 | Jeff Burroughs | Texas Rangers | | | 1975 | Dave Kingman | New York Mets | 4 |
| 1976 | Tom Grieve | Texas Rangers | | | 1976 | Dave Kingman | New York Mets | 5 |
| 1977 | Lee May | Baltimore Orioles | 1 | | 1977 | Dave Kingman | NYAL/SD/CAL/NYNL | 6 |
| 1978 | Lee May | Baltimore Orioles | 2 | | 1978 | Dale Murphy | Atlanta Braves | 1 |
| 1979 | Butch Hobson | Boston Red Sox | | | 1979 | Bill Robinson | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 1980 | Gorman Thomas | Milwaukee Brewers | | | 1980 | Jerry Martin | Chicago Cubs | |
| 1981 | Tony Armas | Oakland Athletics | 1 | | 1981 | Dave Kingman | New York Mets | 7 |
| 1982 | Tony Armas | Oakland Athletics | 2 | | 1982 | Dave Kingman | New York Mets | 8 |
| 1983 | Tony Armas | Boston Red Sox | 3 | | 1983 | George Foster | New York Mets | |
| 1984 | Ron Kittle | Chicago White Sox | | | 1984 | Mike Marshall | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 1985 | Dave Kingman | Oakland Athletics | 9 | | 1985 | Andre Dawson | Montreal Expos | 1 |
| 1986 | Dave Kingman | Oakland Athletics | 10 | | 1986 | Steve Garvey | San Diego Padres | |
| 1987 | Cory Snyder | Cleveland Indians | | | 1987 | Gary Carter | New York Mets | |
| 1988 | Steve Balboni | Kansas City/Seattle | | | 1988 | Dale Murphy | Atlanta Braves | 2 |
| 1989 | Joe Carter | Cleveland Indians | 1 | | 1989 | Dale Murphy | Atlanta Braves | 3 |
| 1990 | Pete Incaviglia | Texas Rangers | | | 1990 | Joe Carter | San Diego Padres | 2 |
| 1991 | Rob Deer | Detroit Tigers | | | 1991 | Andre Dawson | Chicago Cubs | 2 |
| 1992 | George Bell | Chicago White Sox | | | 1992 | Matt Williams | San Francisco Giants | |
| 1993 | Ruben Sierra | Oakland Athletics | 1 | | 1993 | Eric Karros | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 1994 | Ruben Sierra | Oakland Athletics | 2 | | 1994 | Phil Plantier | San Diego Padres | |
| 1995 | Joe Carter | Toronto Blue Jays | 3 | | 1995 | Greg Colbrunn | Florida Marlins | |
| 1996 | Craig Paquette | Kansas City Royals | | | 1996 | Ryne Sandberg | Chicago Cubs | |
| 1997 | Dean Palmer | Texas/Kansas City | | | 1997 | Sammy Sosa | Chicago Cubs | |
| | Joe Carter | Toronto Blue Jays | 4 | | | | | |
| 1998 | Ed Sprague | Toronto Blue Jays | | | 1998 | Shane Andrews | Montreal Expos | |
| 1999 | Russ Davis | Seattle Mariners | | | 1999 | Ruben Rivera | San Diego Padres | |
| 2000 | Jose Cruz, Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | | | 2000 | Kevin Young | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 2001 | Tony Batista | Baltimore Orioles | 1 | | 2001 | Jose Hernandez | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 2002 | Jose Valentin | Chicago White Sox | 1 | | 2002 | Aaron Boone | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 2003 | Tony Batista | Baltimore Orioles | 2 | | 2003 | Alex Gonzalez | Chicago Cubs | |
| 2004 | Jose Valentin | Chicago White Sox | 2 | | 2004 | Tony Batista | Montreal Expos | 3 |
| 2005 | Casey Blake | Cleveland Indians | | | 2005 | Pedro Feliz | San Francisco Giants | |
| 2006 | Juan Uribe | Chicago White Sox | 1 | | 2006 | Pedro Feliz | San Francisco Giants | 2 |
| 2007 | Juan Uribe | Chicago White Sox | 2 | | 2006 | Chris B. Young | Arizona Diamondbacks | |
|