Year	American League		National League
2008	Marcus Thames	Detroit Tigers	Mike Jacobs	Florida Marlins
2007	Juan Uribe 2	Chicago White Sox	Chris B. Young	Arizona Diamondbacks
2006	Juan Uribe 1	Chicago White Sox	Pedro Feliz 2	San Francisco Giants
2005	Casey Blake	Cleveland Indians	Pedro Feliz 1	San Francisco Giants
2004	Jose Valentin 2	Chicago White Sox	Tony Batista 3	Montreal Expos
2003	Tony Batista 2	Baltimore Orioles	Alex Gonzalez	Chicago Cubs
2002	Jose Valentin 1	Chicago White Sox	Aaron Boone	Cincinnati Reds
2001	Tony Batista 1	Baltimore Orioles	Jose Hernandez	Milwaukee Brewers
2000	Jose Cruz, Jr.	Toronto Blue Jays	Kevin Young	Pittsburgh Pirates
1999	Russ Davis	Seattle Mariners	Ruben Rivera	San Diego Padres
1998	Ed Sprague	Toronto Blue Jays	Shane Andrews	Montreal Expos
1997	Dean Palmer	Texas/Kansas City	Sammy Sosa	Chicago Cubs
1997	Joe Carter 4	Toronto Blue Jays
1996	Craig Paquette	Kansas City Royals	Ryne Sandberg	Chicago Cubs
1995	Joe Carter 3	Toronto Blue Jays	Greg Colbrunn	Florida Marlins
1994	Ruben Sierra 2	Oakland Athletics	Phil Plantier	San Diego Padres
1993	Ruben Sierra 1	Oakland Athletics	Eric Karros	Los Angeles Dodgers
1992	George Bell	Chicago White Sox	Matt Williams	San Francisco Giants
1991	Rob Deer	Detroit Tigers	Andre Dawson 2	Chicago Cubs
1990	Pete Incaviglia	Texas Rangers	Joe Carter 2	San Diego Padres
1989	Joe Carter 1	Cleveland Indians	Dale Murphy 3	Atlanta Braves
1988	Steve Balboni	Kansas City/Seattle	Dale Murphy 2	Atlanta Braves
1987	Cory Snyder	Cleveland Indians	Gary Carter	New York Mets
1986	Dave Kingman 10	Oakland Athletics	Steve Garvey	San Diego Padres
1985	Dave Kingman 9	Oakland Athletics	Andre Dawson 1	Montreal Expos
1984	Ron Kittle	Chicago White Sox	Mike Marshall	Los Angeles Dodgers
1983	Tony Armas 3	Boston Red Sox	George Foster	New York Mets
1982	Tony Armas 2	Oakland Athletics	Dave Kingman 8	New York Mets
1981	Tony Armas 1	Oakland Athletics	Dave Kingman 7	New York Mets
1980	Gorman Thomas	Milwaukee Brewers	Jerry Martin	Chicago Cubs
1979	Butch Hobson	Boston Red Sox	Bill Robinson	Pittsburgh Pirates
1978	Lee May 2	Baltimore Orioles	Dale Murphy 1	Atlanta Braves
1977	Lee May 1	Baltimore Orioles	Dave Kingman 6	NYAL/SD/CAL/NYNL
1976	Tom Grieve	Texas Rangers	Dave Kingman 5	New York Mets
1975	Jeff Burroughs	Texas Rangers	Dave Kingman 4	New York Mets
1974	Bobby Darwin	Minnesota Twins	Dave Kingman 3	San Francisco Giants
1973	Carlton Fisk	Boston Red Sox	Dave Kingman 2	San Francisco Giants
1972	George Scott 2	Milwaukee Brewers	Dave Kingman 1	San Francisco Giants
1971	George Scott 1	Boston Red Sox	Johnny Bench	Cincinnati Reds
1970	Bob Oliver	Kansas City Royals	Lee May	Cincinnati Reds
1969	Brooks Robinson	Baltimore Orioles	Ernie Banks 3	Chicago Cubs
1968	Bob Allison	Minnesota Twins	Ernie Banks 2	Chicago Cubs
1967	Mickey Mantle	New York Yankees	Clete Boyer	Atlanta Braves
1966	Joe Pepitone 2	New York Yankees	Leo Cardenas	Cincinnati Reds
1965	Ken Harrelson	Kansas City Athletics	Dick Stuart	Philadelphia Phillies
1964	Joe Pepitone 1	New York Yankees	Frank Howard	Los Angeles Dodgers
1963	Lou Clinton	Boston Red Sox	Ernie Banks 1	Chicago Cubs
1962	Willie Kirkland 2	Cleveland Indians	Joe Adcock	Milwaukee Braves
1961	Willie Kirkland 1	Cleveland Indians	Don Demeter	Los Angeles/Philadelphia
1960	Rocky Colavito	Detroit Tigers	Frank Thomas	Chicago Cubs
1959	Gus Triandos	Baltimore Orioles	Wally Post 3	Philadelphia Phillies
1958	Roger Maris	Cleveland/Kansas City	Bill Mazeroski	Pittsburgh Pirates
1957	Gus Zernial 3	Kansas City Athletics	Wally Post 2	Cincinnati Reds
1956	Hank Bauer	New York Yankees	Del Ennis	Philadelphia Phillies
1955	Gus Zernial 2	Kansas City Athletics	Rip Repulski	Philadelphia Phillies
1954	Roy Sievers	Washington Senators	Wally Post 1	Cincinnati Reds
1953	Eddie Robinson	Philadelphia Athletics	Steve Bilko	St. Louis Cardinals
1952	Walt Dropo	Boston/Detroit	Eddie Mathews	Boston Braves
1951	Ken Wood	St. Louis Browns	Hank Sauer	Chicago Cubs
1950	Gus Zernial 1	Chicago White Sox	Roy Smalley	Chicago Cubs