Advertise on | Player Search by

Advertise | Fan Forum | About Us Contact | Share

TicketCity Baseball Tickets

2009 Philadelphia Phillies: Lightning Doesn't Strike Twice 2009 Spring Preview
by Asher B. Chancey,
March 12, 2009

Key Transactions
Acquired Pos.
Raul Ibanez LF
Gary Majewski RP
Chan Ho Park SP
Ronny Paulino C
Marcus Giles 2B
Miguel Cairo IF
Pablo Ozuna IF
Departed Pos.
Pat Burrell LF
Tom Gordon RP
Rudy Seanez RP
Here's a dumb basis for making a preseason prediction - teams don't repeat in the World Series. The Red Sox won it twice in four years despite being excellent every year. The Cardinals went twice in three years despite having roughly the same lineup each year. With the notable exception of the late-1990s Yankees, teams just don't go to the World Series two years in a row.

That said, the Philadelphia Phillies were actually not as good as they should have been in 2008, which makes you think the 2009 rendition of the team should be better than the World Series winning team of last season. We'll see.

If the number one problem for Phillies fans is the fact that teams don't repeat in the World Series, the number two problem for the team is that there is NO WAY that the New York Mets can blow the division three years in a row. Despite the enormous talent of the Philadelphia Phillies, the Mets are a more talented team.

Could the Mets possibly blow it again?

2008 Standings - NL East
East W L PCT GB Home Road RS RA Exp W% RHP LHP
Philadelphia Phillies 92 70 .568 0 48-33 44-37 799 680 .573 60-48 32-22
New York Mets 89 73 .549 3 48-33 41-40 799 715 .551 55-51 34-22
Florida Marlins 84 77 .522 7.5 45-36 39-41 770 767 .502 62-56 22-21
Atlanta Braves 72 90 .444 20 43-38 29-52 753 778 .485 52-57 20-33
Washington Nationals 59 102 .366 32.5 34-46 25-56 641 825 .387 37-66 22-36

Very few bad offensive players have the fan followings that Carlos Ruiz and Chris Coste have developed playing Catcher for the Phillies. Neither player contributes anything,
Projected Catcher
Carlos Ruis
Chris Coste

Last year:
Carlos Ruis
Chris Coste

and yet Ruiz has a following and Coste is afforded cult hero status.

Projected First Base
Ryan Howard

Last year:
Ryan Howard

Here is my number one fear for the 2009 Phillies - the combination of Ryan Howard's gaudy homerun and RBI totals and a World Series title has allowed Phillies fans, management, and - most importantly - Ryan Howard to conveniently overlook the fact that Howard declined for the second year in a row, failed to show up for most of the first half of the season, hits significantly worse on the road than at home, and has major holes in his game. Throw the complacency that a new contract can often buy, and Ryan Howard could have a very down season at First Base for the Phillies.

In my opinion, Chase Utley is ten times the player Ryan Howard is, but he is not without issues of his own. An excellent hitter with killer Second Base defense, Utley posted a 1.195 OPS in April but failed to get his OPS over .900 in any other month. By the second half of the season, he looked tired and very likely injured. Utley is one of the rare players who can play lights out offense and defense, and to say he had a "down" year last year is somewhat absurd. Nevertheless, he can do better, which he hopes to prove. It should be reiterated that Chase was rumored to have been hampered by injury last year.

Projected Second Base
Chase Utley

Last year:
Chase Utley

One thing I'd like to see Utley work on in 2009 is NOT getting hit by pitches. He has led the league in that category in each of the last two years despite missing thirty games in 2007 because he - wait for it - broke his arm getting hit by a pitch. Utley is well on pace to break Craig Biggio's record for HBP, but I'd rather have him in the lineup than on base fifteen to twenty more times.

Marcus Giles is vying for a spot on the Phillies roster as a backup middle infielder. Hard to believe this guy can't find work. He'll only be 31 this season, and as a recently as 2005 he looked like an elite second baseman. It just goes to show you - if you are trying to resurrect your career, don't do it at Petco Park.

I don't know if I've ever put this on paper, but if Pedro Feliz had played shortstop instead of Third Base, his life would have been so much easier. His defense is incredible, and that plus a light bat just doesn't fly
Projected Third Base
Pedro Feliz
Greg Dobbs

Last year:
Pedro Feliz
Greg Dobbs

at third base the way it does at shortstop. Feliz had an up and down season; relegated to platoon status, he nevertheless started 129 games at third (platoon what?). He had 14 homeruns, 19 doubles, 43 runs, and 58 RBI, all career lows, but he got his on-base percentage over .300 for the first time since 2004 and for only the second time ever. More importantly, he stabilized the third base position on the field in ways that can't quite be comprehended. Which is what he's always done.

How ridiculous are Phillies fans? After Jimmy Rollins won the 2007 NL MVP, he was given a grace period of about twenty minutes before Phillies fans started booing him for struggling at the plate as he recovered from an early season injury. How badly did the Phillie Shortstop struggle? Well, he matched the previous year's doubles total and set career highs for walks, stolen
Projected Shortstop
Jimmy Rollins

Last year:
Jimmy Rollins

bases, and stolen base percentage despite missing 25 games. In 2009, Rollins will be 30 years old and in his ninth full season - could he be turning the corner to the second half of a Hall of Fame career? Are we speaking too soon?

In 2009, the Phillies' Outfield will be without Pat Burrell for the first time since 1999. As the first overall pick in the 1998 draft, Burrell, along with Donovan McNabb (second overall, 1999) and Allen Iverson (first overall, 1996), make up the Holy Trinity of the city of Philadelphia's highly-touted, highly-drafted, moderately successful players from the late-1990s that Philly fans love to hate.

How bad was it for Pat Burrell? In 2008, he was 31 years old and had 33 homeruns, 21.1 adjusted batting runs, and a 125 OPS+. He is being replaced by Raul
MVP Candidate
Chase Utley
Part of first ever All MVP Double Play Combo?
I Dare You To Do It Again
Brad Lidge
I say, come out and blow your first save so we can move on.
Ibanez, a guy who was 36 years old, had 23 homeruns, 22.5 batting runs, and a 123 OPS+ last year. And the Philly fans are euphoric.

Too be sure, Burrell was no clutch hitter and his defense left a lot to be desired. I just think he and Ibanez are a whole lot closer to each other than Phillies fans think.

Projected Outfield
Raul Ibanez
Shane Victorino
Jayson Werth

Last year:
Pat Burrell
Shane Victorino
Jayson Werth
Geoff Jenkins
Eric Bruntlett

good is the Phillies' offense? In 2008 Shane Victorino had a .352 on-base percentage in 146 games and managed to score 102 runs. Meanwhile, in Seattle, Ichiro Suzuki had a .361 on-base percentage in 162 games and scored only 103 runs.

This offense makes ordinary players look like stars.

All kidding aside, Victorino is an absolute sparkplug on offense, and fantastic in the field. He is one of those blue collar Billy Hatcher/Mark Lemke/Scott Brosius guys that you always see on championship teams and that are always missing on teams that thought they'd be in the World Series but aren't.

Jayson Werth finally gets the look I thought he deserved last year in right field. He hit 24 homeruns in 418 at-bats last year... what's to come if he gets 600? He also hit better on the road than at home, which is an asset when you hit in a hitter's park. Of course, 16 of his homeruns came in his 171 plate appearances against lefties, while only eight came in his 311 plate appearances against righties. we'll have to hope for lefties!

Cole Hamels
The Phillies' Starting Rotation is a real good news/bad news situation right now. Good news - Cole Hamels has emerged as the staff ace the Phils hoped he become when they drafted him in the first round of the 2002 draft. Additionally, after a bumpy re-entry, Brett Myers seems to have emerged from his experiment as a relief pitcher to become an even better starter than he was before the move (3.06 second half ERA).

Thus, the top two slots in the rotation look pretty good. Unfortunately, after that the Phillies may have to pray for rain.

In Joe Blanton, the Phillies have acquired a guy whose "get guys out on his own" ability is very low. Since his splashy debut in 2005, he has been a league average (or below) pitcher who can't strike guys out, gets hit a lot, and is not such a ground ball pitcher that he can afford to pitch in Citizen's Bank Park.

It is ironic, then,
Projected Rotation
Cole Hamels
Brett Myers
Joe Blanton
Jamie Moyer
Chan Ho Park
Kyle Kendrick
J.A. Happ

Last year:
Cole Hamels
Brett Myers
Joe Blanton
Kyle Kendrick
Adam Eaton

that the Phils have knocked Kyle Kendrick off the starting staff depth chart, since he and Blanton are clones in those regards.

After Blanton, the Phillies now have Jamie Moyer, the ageless wonder, in the fourth slot. Moyer went 16-7 with a 3.71 ERA for the Phils last year, and with their lineup, they probably just need him to eat his standard 190-210 innings again this year. At the same time, he's 46 years old. Eventually, his arm does have to fall off, right?

Phillies Fun Fact
Phillies' starting pitcher Jamie Moyer made his Major League debut two years before Phillies' ace Cole Hamels' mother was born.
Which brings us to the number five slot in the rotation. The Phillies are doing something which is probably admirable: letting three guys fight it out for the final spot. The problem is, of these guys, you really don't want two of them in your rotation, so when one of the three has a good spring, and it just so happens to be one of the bad ones, you're screwed.

Such is the case with the Phillies. The three players? J.A. Happ, Kyle Kendrick, and none other than Chan Ho freakin' Park.

I must say, I think there are times when you let players duke it out for the starting job and let the best man win, and then there are times to keep your wits about you and play the better player. From 2000 to 2008, Chan Ho Park had a season with a 133 ERA+, a 125 ERA+, a 113 ERA+, and then six seasons of ERA+ under (usually well under) 100. Those three good years? All came in Dodgers Stadium, in 2000, 2001, and 2008. All those other years? Mainly Texas, but also San Diego and New York, homes to two of very friendly pitcher's parks.

And what are the Phillies potentially going to pass on? J.A. Happ is a 26-year old, 6-foot-6, 200-pound lefty with 545 strikeouts and a 3.34 ERA in 528.2 minor league innings. Last season at Triple-A, he went 8-7, 151/48, 3.60 in 135 innings pitched.

If the Phils go with Park over Happ, it will be a sizeable error.

Phillies Team Capsule

6/27/10: A New Home Run King - No, Barry Bonds' record of 762 home runs has not fallen. Instead, Jaime Moyer gave up the 506th homer of his career on Sunday, breaking the record previously held by ex-Phillie Robin Roberts for over 50 years.

Moyer's home run - surrendered to the resurgent Vernon Wells - was his one mistake in an 11-2 victory that marked Moyer's ninth win of the season. Moyer appears to be a lock to break Phil Niekro's record 11 victories in a season by a 47-year-old pitcher set back in 1986.

I suppose I should address Kyle Kendrick. He has now made 50 major league starts in two seasons, and he has a 21-13 record. This makes Kendrick Exhibit A in the "How won-loss records can be misleading" presentation. His career strikeout ratios - both per inning and vs walks - are amongst the worst for full time major leaguers in the last two years. He gets less than a strikeout every other inning, and he gets almost as many walks as strikeouts. He is hittable, and he led the National League in hit batsmen in 2008.

In short, Kendrick is not a major league talent, and should not be treated as such. He could be a poor man's Derek Lowe if he worked on his "stuff," but he is not that pitcher yet.

Know what makes the
Projected Bullpen
Brad Lidge
Ryan Madson
J.C. Romero
Rudy Seanez
Clay Condrey
Tom Gordon
Scott Eyre

Last year:
Brad Lidge
Ryan Madson
J.C. Romero
Rudy Seanez
Clay Condrey
Scott Eyre

Brad Lidge trade the Phillies made last off-season so great? The main piece of the deal from the Phillies' side was Michael Bourn, who only would have hurt the Phils had he continued to take up at-bats in the order.

It is tough to get a feel for Brad Lidge and the 2009 Phillies Bullpen. In six major league seasons, Lidge has given us six different looks: 2003's Nice Find; 2004's Utter Dominance; 2005's Excellent but not Dominant; 2006's Houston We Have a Problem; 2007's Back on Track; and 2008's This Guy Really Knows How to Pitch.

My problem with Lidge is that come rain or come shine, he has always walked too many guys; in his bad years, he also gives up homeruns, hits batters, and throws wild pitches. The test of the Lidge is how well he can avoid the mistakes.

I don't know what secret ingredient makes a championship team, but I do know that outstanding middle relief so often appears to be part of the mix. Last season, J.C. Romero, Ryan Madson, Chad Durbin, Clay Condrey, Rudy Seanez, and Scott Eyre all scored 124 or higher on the ERA+ scale. I am pretty sure that having six relievers pitch on that level is incredibly rare. I am also pretty sure this crew is not bound for a repeat performance. Seanez is gone, Romero starts the year suspended for 50 games, only Madson has truly good stuff, and the rest of these guys are real on again/off again guys who don't quite seem to have what it takes to maintain dominance year in and year out.

Outlook for the Season

I don't anticipate the Braves, Nationals, or Marlins being able to mount much of an attack on the top of the NL East this season. This division will once again come down to the Phillies and the Mets.

Frankly, the time when I supposed the Mets to be more talented than the Phils may be coming to an end. Obviously, the Mets are now ridiculously strong in the bullpen, and still have two of the game's brightest young stars in David Wright and Jose Reyes. But I think these Phillies hitters are younger and more talented overall than the Mets'. The Mets' pitching staff is in disarray, which only Johan Santana having ever put together a consistent season, while the Phils actually look pretty good in that regard (but it has to be Happ).

It is only the unlikelihood of a team winning back-to-back World Series titles combined with the unlikelihood of the New York Mets blowing the NL East down the stretch three years in a row that makes me doubt these Philadelphia Phillies. This is a team that features an excellent mix of young, exciting baseball players coming into their primes, players currently enjoying their primes, and veterans with experience. This is also a team with talent coming out of its ears. There is nothing to dislike. It just doesn't seem likely to happen twice in a row, that's all.

Of course, I think supposing that this team misses the playoffs this year would be absurd.

Team Previews Index

Do you have a different take? Send your opinions to

Random Player

Become a Fan on Facebook

Our Friends

Latest Headlines
Top 15 Not in the
Hall of Fame

How Good Is
Mike Trout?

10th Annual
Fielding Bible Awards

More News, Notes, and Headlines

New Baseball Voices audio CD available in The Baseball Evolution Store:

Ron Santo: Cubs Legend

Pat Hughes and Ron Santo were the Chicago Cubs' WGN Radio announcing team for 15 seasons. Their unique on-air chemistry became known as "the Pat and Ron Show" with fans tuning in as much for their eccentric banter as for Cubs baseball itself.

Hot Baseball Tickets!
Texas Rangers
Philadelphia Phillies
Miami Marlins
Detroit Tigers
LA Angels

2009 Baseball Evolution Team Previews
NL EastNL CentralNL WestAL EastAL CentralAL West
Atlanta Braves
Florida Marlins
New York Mets
Philadelphia Phillies
Washington Nationals
Chicago Cubs
Cincinnati Reds
Houston Astros
Milwaukee Brewers
Pittsburgh Pirates
St. Louis Cardinals
Arizona Diamondbacks
Colorado Rockies
Los Angeles Dodgers
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants
Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox
New York Yankees
Tampa Bay Devil Rays
Toronto Blue Jays
Chicago White Sox
Cleveland Indians
Detroit Tigers
Kansas City Royals
Minnesota Twins
Los Angeles Angels
Oakland Athletics
Texas Rangers
Seattle Mariners
Player Rankings | Hall of Fame | Statistics | Heated Debates | Teams | Predictions
Keith | Asher | Tony | Richard | Gregory
About Us | Advertising | Submissions | Facebook is licensed under a Creative Commons License