| Awards | American League | National League |
| Most Valuable Player | Grady Sizemore (.320-30-108) | Chase Utley (.328-28-110) |
| Cy Young | Felix Hernandez (18-6 3.06) | Johan Santana (20-7 2.75) |
| Rookie of the Year | Evan Longoria (.280-21-84) | Kosuke Fukodome (.280-21-90) |
| Comeback Player | Travis Hafner (.290-40-121) | Jason Bay (.300-28-105) |
| Surprise Player | Asdrubal Cabrera (.285-15-75) | Kelly Johnson (.310-16-74) |
| Disappointing Player | Daisuke Matsuzaka (14-13 4.50) | Brad Lidge (4.10 8BSV) |
| Dave Kingman | Delmon Young (.270-20HR-18BB) | Pedro Feliz .260 26 HR 15 BB |
| Alex Gonzalez of the Marlins | Curtis Granderson | Khalil Greene |
| Mark Redman | Fausto Carmona | John Maine |