| Awards | American League | National League |
| Most Valuable Player | Grady Sizemore (.295-34-102) | Albert Pujols (.366-47-136) |
| Cy Young | Roy Halladay (23-7 3.03) | Ubaldo Jimenez (18-4 3.38) |
| Rookie of the Year | Travis Snider (.321-15-77) | Dexter Fowler (.299-8-52) |
| Comeback Player | Paul Konerko (.289-32-101) | Chris Young (13-9 3.36) |
| Surprise Player | Josh Fields (.280-35-94) | Khalil Greene (.280-31-111) |
| Disappointing Player | Matt Holliday (.278-20-88) | Orlando Hudson (.244-12-54) |
| Dave Kingman | Mike Jacobs (.233-35-81) | Jay Bruce (.259-26-78) |
| Alex Gonzalez of the Marlins | Ken Griffey (.874/.691) | Jayson Werth (.909/.668) |
| Josh Towers | Gavin Floyd (4-14 6.62) | Jon Garland (8-16 5.84) |
| Mark Redman | Edwin Jackson (2.99/7.06) | Clayton Kershaw (3.24/6.49) |
