by Richard Van Zandt, BaseballEvolution.com
October 23, 2012
Riding the well rested back of 2011 AL MVP Justin Verlander,
along with 2012 triple crown winner Miguel Cabrera and marquee offseason
acqusition Prince Fielder, the Detroit Tigers will take the field Wednesday at
AT&T Park in Game 1 of the 108th World Series as the clear Las Vegas
favorites, despite having won six fewer games during the regular season than
their opponent, the San Francisco Giants. The Giants, who will be playing for
their second Series championship in the last three years, get the slight even
though they have home field advantage, a distinction earned in no small part
because ace Justin Verlander was rocked soundly in the All-Star game (1 IP, 4 H,
2 BB, 5 R), with a large chunk of the damage being inflicted by players wearing
the Orange and Black.
One thing is shaping up to be certain. Baseball fans are in
for a wild ride.
The Tigers come into San Francisco having not played a game
since last Thursday, when they completed a four-game sweep of the mighty New
York Yankees, while the Giants take the field on Wednesday fresh off a dramatic
come-from-behind series win over the defending champion St. Louis Cardinals just
two days earlier. Whether that added extra rest translates into an advantage is
yet to be seen, but three times since the LCS expanded to a best-of-seven format
has a team that completed a four-game sweep advanced to face a team that went
the full seven. In all three instances, the team with less rest won handily.
San Francisco, meanwhile, rolls into the Series overflowing
with confidence after winning six straight elimination games this post-season
alone, but they’ll run into a buzz-saw named Verlander in Game 1, and he’ll be
followed by a group of starters that collectively has posted a 1.02 ERA over the
first nine games of the 2012 playoffs.
Positional Edge
Catcher
Detroit – Alex Avila (2012 Post-Season: .227/.227/.409)
San Francisco – Buster Posey (2012 PS: .178/.288/.311)
Avila had a strong year defensively, but his offensive
numbers were down from his breakout 2011 campaign. He homered in the division
series against Oakland, but otherwise has collected just 3 singles in 21 at bats
this October. But he works well with his staff, especially Verlander, who had a
2.46 ERA during the regular season with Avila behind the dish, a mark that
dropped to 0.74 during the post-season.
Meanwhile Posey is the NL Comeback Player of the Year award
winner and the likely MVP. Yet aside from one majestic blast against Mat Latos
of the Reds, he has struggled at the plate in the playoffs. His performance
during the Series could go a long way towards determining who comes out on top.
Edge: Giants
First Base
Detroit – Prince Fielder (2012 PS: .211/.268/.289)
San Francisco – Brandon Belt (2012 PS: .222/.300/.389)
The A’s and Yankees did a good job of keeping Fielder in
check during the first two rounds, holding the big fella to just one home run
and 7 singles in 41 plate appearances. San Francisco pitchers have had some
measure of success against him in the past, allowing only 5 home runs to Fielder
in 44 career games, and they’ll need to replicate that success in the Series.
After going just 1-for-13 against the Reds, Belt got hot
during the NLCS, batting .304 and slugging .565, including going 4-for-9 in the
final two games. He’s not in Fielder’s league at the plate, but he held his own
against the Cardinals, and he’s got the decided advantage with the glove.
Edge: Tigers
Second Base
Detroit – Omar Infante (2012 PS: .286/.324/.314)
San Francisco – Marco Scutaro (2012 PS: .354/.404/.438 –
NLCS MVP)
Infante came over in the July deal that delivered Anibal
Sanchez to the Tigers, and hit .257 with a .668 OPS in 64 games for Detroit,
after batting .287 with a .754 OPS in 85 games for Miami. He stepped it up and
hit .353 in the division series against Oakland, but had just four singles in 18
at bats against New York. His glove, however, helped solidify the second base
position.
Scutaro, meanwhile, came to San Francisco in what has
turned out to be perhaps the biggest deadline deal of Brian Sabean’s tenure as
GM of the Giants. Scutaro hit .362 in 61 regular season games and .354 in his
first 12 post-season matches, while collecting 14 hits in the NLCS to tie a
championship series record. He also flashed some fancy leather during the series
and overcame a hip strain caused by Matt Holliday’s illegal barrel roll slide in
Game 1 to win the Most Valuable Player award.
Edge: Giants
Shortstop
Detroit – Jhonny Peralta (2012 PS: .343/.361/.543)
San Francisco – Brandon Crawford (2012 PS: .206/.325/.294)
Peralta had a sub-par year at the plate, but has turned it
up a notch in the playoffs, particularly against the Yankees, against whom he
batted .389 with 2 home runs in the four game set. He’s solid in the field
according to UZR (9.9), though John Dewan’s +/- rating system doesn’t like him
as much (-1 defensive run saved).
Crawford, a future Gold Glove winner, hit just .217 against
the Cardinals, but drove in five runs and played outstanding defense in a series
where defensive miscues at shortstop for St. Louis were a big key to San
Francisco’s comeback.
Edge: Tigers
Third Base
Detroit – Miguel Cabrera (2012 PS: .278/.366/.444)
San Francisco – Pablo Sandoval (2012 PS: .320/.346/.580)
After a slow start to his 2012 post-season (.250 in five
games vs. Oak), the triple crown winning Cabrera found the Yankees pitching much
more to his liking, driving in four runs in the four game set, and slugging
.563. The portly Panda, meanwhile, has driven in nine runs in 12 playoff games,
with 3 home runs for San Francisco, and despite his girth, is the more
fundamentally sound defensive player. Cabrera is the world’s best pure hitter,
but Sandoval’s no slouch at the plate himself and his glove work makes the gap
smaller than most would credit him for.
Edge: Tigers
Outfield
Detroit – Austin Jackson (2012 PS: .297/.350/.514), Delmon
Young (2012 PS: .294/.351/.500 – ALCS MVP), Andy Dirks (2012 PS:
.257/.278/.314), Quintin Berry (2012 PS: .278/.316/.389), Avisail Garcia (2012
PS: .333/.368/.389)
San Francisco – Angel Pagan (2012 PS: .208/.246/.377),
Gregor Blanco (2012 PS: .222/.364/.417), Hunter Pence (2012 PS: .188/.204/.271),
Xavier Nady (2012 PS: 0-for-5, 1 BB)
The Tigers outfield is young – at 27, Delmon Young and
rookie Quintin Berry are the oldest of the group – and talented. The speedy
Berry was 21-for-21 in stolen bases during the regular season, and 2-for-2 in
the playoffs, while the 21-year old Garcia has played in only 23 regular season
games, but hit .455 against the Yankees in the ALCS. Jackson, the leader of the
group, had his best big league season and hit .353 with a double, a triple and a
home run against New York. Where you might see the Giants home field advantage
benefit them the most, however, is when the defensively challenged Young is
forced to take the field at spacious AT&T Park. Detroit will look to get the
lead early in those games, and turn to Dirks or Berry for defense in the later
innings.
As motivational as his pre-game speeches have been, the
Giants will need the Reverend Hunter Pence to produce a bit more at the plate in
the Series, though some might suggest that divine intervention was involved with
his thrice struck, broken bat, backspin loaded, three-run double in Game 7 of
the NLCS. Blanco and Pagan, both garnering their first major league post-season
experience, have covered a lot of ground in the outfield, but the Giants would
surely benefit from the two speedsters reaching base more often during the
Series. Pagan did have three multi-hit games in the NLCS and could be primed to
break out big in his first World Series.
Edge: Even
Starting Pitching
Detroit – Justin Verlander (2012 PS: 3-0, 0.74 ERA), Doug
Fister (2012 PS: 0-0, 1.35 ERA), Anibal Sanchez (2012 PS: 1-1, 1.35 ERA), Max
Scherzer (2012 PS: 1-0, 0.82 ERA)
San Francisco – Barry Zito (2012 PS: 1-0, 1.75 ERA),
Madison Bumgarner (2012 PS: 0-2, 11.25 ERA), Ryan Vogelsong (2012 PS: 2-0, 1.42
ERA), Matt Cain (2012 PS: 2-2, 3.52 ERA)
Verlander, the best pitcher in the universe, is followed in
the rotation by Fister in Game 2, Sanchez in Game 3, and Scherzer in Game 4.
That foursome allowed just 35 hits in 62 innings of work in the first two rounds
of post-season play, holding hitters to a .162 batting average, and they
represent the Tigers best hope for their first World Series title since 1984.
Verlander matches up against Zito, who pitched the game of his Giants career
(7.2 IP, 0 R) in St. Louis in Game 5 of the NLCS, after getting just 8 outs
against the Reds in the NLDS. The Giants have won 13 straight starts by Zito,
however, and view him as their lucky charm. San Francisco will hope Bumgarner
has indeed worked out the flaws in his delivery, or you will see their wild
card, two-time Cy Young winner Tim Lincecum, out of the bullpen early. The
best-pitched game of the Series may just end up being Game 3, when Vogelsong
faces off against Sanchez. Sanchez, acquired from Miami in July, has a 1.98
career ERA in five starts against the Giants, while Vogelsong has allowed just 4
earned runs over his last 36 innings (1.00 ERA) dating back to September 21.
Those two could potentially meet up again in a Game 7 at AT&T, where Sanchez
sports a nifty 0.36 ERA in 3 starts. Max Scherzer, whose 11.1 K/9 lead the
majors, duels Giants ace Matt Cain in Game 4.
Edge: Tigers
Relief Pitching
Detroit – Jose Valverde (2012 PS: 0-1, 27.04 ERA), Phil
Coke (2012 PS: 0-0, 0.00 ERA, 2 SV), Joaquin Benoit (2012 PS: 0-0, 4.91 ERA),
Octavio Dotel (2012 PS: 0-0, 0.00 ERA), Al Alburquerque (2012 PS: 1-0, 0.00
ERA), Drew Smyly (2012 PS: 1-0, 0.00 ERA), Rick Porcello (2012 PS: 0-0, 0.00
ERA)
San Francisco – Sergio Romo (2012 PS: 1-0, 1.17 ERA, 1 SV),
Santiago Casilla (2012 PS: 0-0, 1.59 ERA), Javier Lopez (2012 PS: 0-0, 0.00
ERA), Jeremy Affeldt (2012 PS: 0-0, 0.00 ERA), Jose Mijares (2012 PS: 0-0, 11.59
ERA), Guillermo Mota (2012 PS: 0-0, 21.56 ERA), Tim Lincecum (2012 PS: 1-1, 3.46
ERA), George Kontos (2012 PS: 0-0 3.60 ERA)
The biggest question of the Series is who will close out
games for Detroit? Tigers skipper Jim Leyland said during the ALCS that Valverde
was still his closer, but that he wouldn’t use him to close out any more games
during that series after Valverde imploded in the ninth inning of Game 1. Lefty
Phil Coke did well against the Yankees, picking up 2 saves, while top setup man
Joaquin Benoit is vulnerable to the long-ball, after having surrendered 14
during the regular season and another in the post-season, so it figures Coke
would be used ahead of Benoit, if Valverde is not up to the task. Aside from
Valverde, however, the Tigers pen has done a fantastic job, allowing just 2
earned runs (both by Benoit) in 18 1/3 innings (0.98 ERA).
Bruce Bochy continued to use his bullpen masterfully
against the Cardinals, and has seen his group of relievers post a 2.57 ERA this
post-season. Tim Lincecum remains the Giants versatile secret weapon out of the
pen, while Romo, Casilla, Lopez and Affeldt have been lights out in the late
innings.
Edge: Even
Prediction
The Tigers 83-year old owner Mike Ilitch has four Stanley
Cup titles in the last 15 years, thanks to his Detroit Red Wings, but it’s a
World Series ring that eludes him, and it’s that want of a ring that drove him
to spend $214 million on Fielder this past winter. GM Dave Dombrowski has built
a team deep in pitching and in hitting. If they have an exploitable weakness,
it’s their defense, which ranked among the worst in the majors in 2012, and in
the post-season, every mistake is amplified. This series will likely come down
to who makes the fewest mistakes, and who comes up with the biggest and the
timeliest clutch hits. You can bet there will be plenty of great pitching to go
around. For me, however, this World Series will come down to who wants it the
most. Judging from how they refused to quit when facing elimination six straight
times, that’s got to be the Giants.
San
Francisco in a wild seven games
Disagree with something? Got something to add? Wanna bring up something totally new? Richard resides in San Francisco, California and can be reached at richard@baseballevolution.com.