| Player | Date | Inning |
| Neal Ball - SS | July 19, 1909 | 2nd |
| Cleveland Indians | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| Bill Wambsganss - 2B | October 10, 1920 | 5th |
| Cleveland Indians | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| George Burns - 1B | September 14, 1923 | 2nd |
| Boston Red Sox | | |
| liner - tagged man off 1st. tag 2nd before man returned. | | |
| Ernie Padgett - SS | October 6, 1923 | 4th |
| Boston Braves | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| Glenn Wright - SS | May 7, 1925 | 9th |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner going back to 1st. | | |
| Jimmy Cooney - SS | May 30, 1927 | 4th |
| Chicago Cubs | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| Johnny Neun - 1B | May 31, 1927 | 9th |
| Detroit tigers | | |
| liner - tagged man off 1st. tag 2nd before man returned. | | |
| Ron Hansen - SS | July 30, 1968 | 1st |
| Washington Senators | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| Mickey Morandini - 2B | September 20, 1992 | 6th |
| Philadelphia Phillies | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| John Valentin - SS | July 8, 1994 | 6th |
| Boston Red Sox | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner coming from 1st. | | |
| Randy Velarde - 2B | May 29, 2000 | 6th |
| Oakland Athletics | | |
| liner - tagged runner coming from 1st. touched 2nd. | | |
| Rafael Furcal - SS | August 10, 2003 | 5th |
| Atlanta Braves | | |
| liner - touched 2nd. tagged runner going back to 1st. | | |
