BaseballEvolution.com - Top 100 - Keith, Scott, and Asher Composite List

Rank	Player	Composite Score	Keith 2004	Scott 2004	Asher 2004
1	Babe  Ruth	1.00	1	1	1
2	Ty  Cobb	2.00	2	2	2
3	Walter  Johnson	3.00	3	3	3
4	Ted Williams	5.00	5	5	5
5	Rogers Hornsby	5.33	4	6	6
6	Honus Wagner	6.33	6	4	9
6	Barry Bonds	6.33	7	8	4
8	Lou Gerhig	8.67	9	10	7
9	Willie Mays	9.00	10	7	10
10	Mickey Mantle	10.33	8	9	14
11	Stan Musial	12.00	13	11	12
12	Tris Speaker	12.33	12	14	11
13	Hank Aaron	13.67	11	12	18
13	Cy Young	13.67	15	18	8
15	Eddie Collins	15.00	14	15	16
16	Mike Schmidt	17.33	16	17	19
17	Jimmie Foxx	17.67	22	16	15
18	Pete Alexander	18.33	20	22	13
19	Mel Ott	19.67	17	20	22
20	Rickey Henderson	21.00	19	24	20
21	Lefty Grove	21.67	21	13	31
22	Roger Clemens	22.00	23	26	17
23	Frank Robinson	23.67	25	23	23
24	Nap Lajoie	24.33	27	21	25
25	Joe DiMaggio	25.00	28	19	28
25	Joe Morgan	25.00	24	25	26
27	Christy Mathewson	26.00	30	27	21
27	Eddie Mathews	26.00	18	28	32
29	Greg Maddux	28.67	26	31	29
30	Johnny Mize	32.33	31	36	30
31	Arky Vaughan	32.67	29	34	35
32	Joe Jackson	33.67	42	32	27
33	Hank Greenberg	34.33	41	38	24
34	George Brett	34.67	32	33	39
35	Tom Seaver	35.67	44	30	33
36	Randy Johnson	39.00	39	37	41
37	Bill Dickey	40.33	33	54	34
38	Mark McGwire	42.67	34	42	52
39	Jeff Bagwell	43.33	40	41	49
39	Frank Thomas	43.33	37	48	45
41	Yogi Berra	43.67	43	51	37
42	Sam Crawford	44.33	50	40	43
43	Charlie Gerhinger	44.67	51	47	36
44	Carl Yastrzemski	45.33	69	29	38
44	Jackie Robinson	45.33	57	35	44
46	Mike Piazza	46.00	38	60	40
47	Wade Boggs	46.33	35	44	60
48	Johnny Bench	49.67	46	56	47
49	Reggie Jackson	51.33	47	46	61
50	Harry Heilmann	52.00	49	65	42
51	Carl Hubbell	53.33	65	49	46
52	Ken Griffey, Jr.	53.67	56	50	55
53	Willie McCovey	54.67	55	52	57
54	Mickey Cochrane	57.67	45	64	64
55	Bob Gibson	59.67	73	55	51
55	Tony Gwynn	59.67	66	43	70
57	Harmon Killebrew	60.67	62	62	58
58	Cal Ripken, Jr.	61.67	98	39	48
58	Pedro Martinez	61.67	36	99	50
60	Willie Stargell	62.67	67	59	62
61	Ed Walsh	63.00	54	81	54
62	Gabby Hartnett	63.67	48	58	85
63	Bob Feller	64.33	58	45	90
63	Tim Raines	64.33	53	72	68
65	Duke Snider	65.67	77	53	67
66	Whitey Ford	67.00	60	75	66
67	Warren Spahn	68.33	79	57	69
67	Home Run Baker	68.33	74	78	53
69	Paul Waner	69.33	59	70	79
70	Rod Carew	70.00	63	63	84
71	Al Simmons	72.33	88	73	56
72	Mordecai Brown	73.33	75	86	59
73	Joe Cronin	73.67	70	76	75
74	Dick Allen	75.33	61	88	77
75	Al Kaline	76.33	64	67	98
76	Hoyt Wilhelm	76.67	52	96	82
77	Eddie Murray	78.00	80	83	71
77	Alex Rodriguez	78.00	68		65
79	Robin Yount	79.33	96	61	81
79	Dave Winfield	79.33	78	80	80
81	Ernie Banks	82.00		69	76
82	Pete Rose	83.00	100	66	83
82	Juan Marichal	83.00		85	63
84	Edgar Martinez	83.67	72		78
85	Ryne Sandberg	85.00		82	72
85	Barry Larkin	85.00	82	79	94
87	Paul Molitor	86.33	85		73
88	Nolan Ryan	87.00		71	89
89	Steve Carlton	90.00		68
90	Ron Santo	90.33	89	89	93
91	Roberto Alomar	90.67	92	93	87
92	Gary Sheffield	91.00	71
93	Luke Appling	91.33	76		97
94	Craig Biggio	91.67	86		88
95	Satchel Paige	92.00		74
95	Addie Joss	92.00			74
97	Roberto Clemente	92.33	99	77
98	Ralph Kiner	92.67	90	87
99	Jim Palmer	94.00	87	94
99	Frankie Frisch	94.00		95	86
99	Minnie Minoso	94.00		90	91
102	Manny Ramirez	94.33	81
103	Bobby Grich	95.00	83
104	Fred Clarke	95.33	84
104	Sammy Sosa	95.33		84
106	Sandy Koufax	96.33		92	96
107	Carlton Fisk	97.33	95	98	99
108	Larry Doby	97.67		91
108	Stan Hack	97.67	91
110	Eddie Plank	98.00			92
111	Roger Bresnahan	98.33	93
112	Kevin Brown	98.67	94
113	Roy Campanella	99.00			95
114	Lou Boudreau	99.67	97
114	Dennis Eckersley	99.67		97
116	Rafael Palmeiro	100.33		100	100