This Could Be Your Ad!
The 2006 BaseballEvolution.com Composite Top 100!
Advertise your business, or send a shout out to your team!

Rank Player Comp Keith Scott Asher Tony Richard
1 Babe Ruth 1 1 1 1 1 1
2 Ty Cobb 2 2 2 2 2 2
3 Walter Johnson 3.8 3 3 3 3 7
4 Ted Williams 4.2 5 5 4 4 3
5 Rogers Hornsby 6.8 4 6 5 6 13
6 Honus Wagner 7 6 4 11 5 9
7 Barry Bonds 7.2 7 7 6 11 5
8 Lou Gehrig 8.2 9 10 7 7 8
9 Willie Mays 8.6 11 8 10 10 4
10 Stan Musial 9.6 10 11 8 8 11
11 Mickey Mantle 10.8 8 9 13 9 15
12 Roger Clemens 12.2 16 12 12 15 6
13 Hank Aaron 12.6 12 13 15 13 10
14 Tris Speaker 14.8 13 15 14 12 20
15 Grover Alexander 18.6 19 21 18 17 18
16 Jimmie Foxx 18.8 22 17 19 22 14
17 Mike Schmidt 20.6 24 22 17 19 21
18 Joe DiMaggio 21.8 28 24 27 18 12
18 Rickey Henderson 21.8 18 20 23 24 24
20 Eddie Collins 22.2 15 16 16 16 48
21 Lefty Grove 22.4 20 14 28 20 30
22 Cy Young 23.2 14 18 9 14 61
23 Frank Robinson 24.6 26 25 22 23 27
24 Mel Ott 24.8 17 19 20 21 47
25 Christy Matthewson 25.8 30 29 21 32 17
26 Greg Maddux 26.4 27 27 25 28 25
27 Nap Lajoie 28.4 23 23 24 29 43
28 Alex Rodriguez 31.6 38 43 26 25 26
29 Randy Johnson 32.8 36 34 29 31 34
30 Joe Morgan 33.4 21 26 31 27 62
31 Tom Seaver 34.4 42 41 37 30 22
32 Hank Greenberg 35.2 37 36 44 36 23
33 Pedro Martinez 36.2 32 38 42 37 32
34 George Brett 36.6 40 32 30 41 40
34 Johnny Mize 36.6 31 33 34 33 52
36 Joe Jackson 37.2 45 30 38 35 38
37 Yogi Berra 37.8 49 39 33 40 28
38 Frank Thomas 39 34 46 32 38 45
39 Eddie Mathews 39.6 25 28 36 26 83
40 Jeff Bagwell 43 39 45 35 39 57
40 Mike Piazza 43 35 37 49 50 44
42 Johnny Bench 43.2 44 52 45 46 29
43 Ken Griffey Jr. 43.8 57 47 47 52 16
44 Bill Dickey 44.2 33 42 40 43 63
45 Charlie Gehringer 44.8 48 50 41 44 41
45 Jackie Robinson 44.8 52 40 53 48 31
47 Arky Vaughan 47.6 29 31 43 34
48 Bob Feller 51.2 61 56 46 47 46
49 Wade Boggs 53.2 43 54 51 49 69
50 Tony Gwynn 53.8 71 53 52 54 39
51 Mark McGwire 55 41 51 54 53 76
52 Sam Crawford 55.2 59 44 39 42 92
53 Carl Yastrzemski 57.2 81 35 69 45 56
53 Mickey Cochrane 57.2 46 66 58 56 60
55 Willie McCovey 58.8 55 59 59 55 66
56 Gary Sheffield 60.6 53 65 63 63 59
56 Whitey Ford 60.6 58 69 62 64 50
58 Warren Spahn 62.8 82 64 71 60 37
59 Paul Waner 63.6 60 74 64 65 55
60 Reggie Jackson 63.8 62 57 48 51
61 Manny Ramirez 64 76 84 70 57 33
62 Harry Heilmann 65.8 54 68 55 51
63 Al Kaline 66.6 73 67 73 71 49
63 Willie Stargell 66.6 77 62 61 66 67
65 Carl Hubbell 68.6 64 55 50 73
66 Harmon Killebrew 72 75 63 60 61
66 Rod Carew 72 63 70 67 62 98
68 Duke Snider 72.4 86 58 81 59 78
69 Bob Gibson 73 67 61 56 99 82
70 Al Simmons 73.2 90 79 86 58 53
71 Mordecai Brown 73.4 72 82 76 83 54
71 Pete Rose 73.4 94 72 91 74 36
73 Craig Biggio 73.8 68 71 75 84 71
74 Satchel Paige 74 48 19
75 Gabby Hartnett 75 47 60 94 81 93
75 Jim Thome 75 80 95 72 70 58
77 Ed Walsh 76.6 50 73 92 67
78 Cal Ripken Jr. 77.2 49 57 85 94
79 Tim Raines 77.6 56 75 84 72
80 Joe Cronin 77.8 79 76 65 68
81 Home Run Baker 80.8 78 78 78 69
82 Dick Allen 84.2 74 83 87 76
82 Eddie Murray 84.2 91 80 77 72
82 Roberto Alomar 84.2 84 93 82 75 87
85 Barry Larkin 84.4 65 81 93 82
85 Chipper Jones 84.4 66 66 88
87 Hoyt Wilhelm 85 51 86 87 100
88 Steve Carlton 85.6 89 80 94 64
89 Ernie Banks 86.4 85 79 90 77
90 Edgar Martinez 86.6 70 83 78
90 Roy Campanella 86.6 95 35
92 Dave Winfield 87.6 95 92 77 89 85
93 Juan Marichal 87.8 99 68 70
93 Paul Molitor 87.8 85 88 79 86
95 Eddie Plank 88.2 97 74 68
96 Ichiro Suzuki 89.2 42
97 Robin Yount 89.8 77 90 86 95
98 Luke Appling 90.4 69 80
99 Roberto Clemente 92 88 91 79
100 Bill Terry 93.8 65
101 Ralph Kiner 94.8 96 87 98 92
102 Carlton Fisk 95.2 99 98 98 80
102 Rafael Palmiero 95.2 89 84
104 Sammy Sosa 95.4 73
105 Ivan Rodriguez 95.6 74
106 Derek Jeter 95.8 75
107 Jim Palmer 96.2 92 94 93
108 Dennis Eckersley 97 81
109 Stan Hack 97.2 87 96
110 Roger Bresnahan 97.4 83
111 Ron Santo 97.6 91 100 95
112 Fergie Jenkins 97.8 85
112 Ryne Sandberg 97.8 97 89
114 Mariano Rivera 98.2 100 88
115 Fred Clarke 98.4 93 96
115 Lou Boudreau 98.4 88
117 Vladimir Guerrero 98.6 89
118 Nolan Ryan 98.8 90
118 Ozzie Smith 98.8 90
120 George Sisler 99 91
121 Frankie Frisch 99.4 96 100 99
122 Larry Doby 99.6 99 96
123 Billy Williams 100.2 97
123 Gary Carter 100.2 97
123 Rube Waddell 100.2 97
126 Bobby Grich 100.4 98
127 Minnie Minoso 100.8 100


Disagree with something? Got something to add? Wanna bring up something totally new? The staff of Baseball Evolution can be reached at comments@baseballevolution.com.



 GO
BaseballEvolution Features



2006 Team Previews
See where we think the teams will finish, and what we have to say about them

Hall of Fame
See who's in, who's out, and where we differ from Cooperstown

The Teams Page
Find about all about your favorite team including Stats Leaders, Awards, Playoff Teams, and More.

Splitsville
Join us as we sift through all kinds of split statistics and divulge what they mean (if anything)

Statistics
Your source for stats, both conventional and otherwise.

Award Room
MVPs, Cy Youngs, Gonzalez's and Kingmans - all of your award info and analysis right here.

Top 100s
See where we rank'em, and how our lists compare to Bill James, Total Baseball, and others.
Trivia
Test your baseball knowledge with our obscure knowledge quizzes!

Predictions
As the season rolls along, check to see how accurate our 2005 predictions were.

Boneheads
See who's making a lot of money to embarrass themselves writing about baseball.

Heated Debates
We don't always agree with each other. In fact, we often don't!

Scorer's Corner
Join Keith in his Scorer's Corner as he shares scoring oddities that he has encountered while scoring Zephyr games.

Scouting Reports
In-depth analysis of various high-level prospects around baseball

Playoff Central
Previews and analysis of all of the exciting postseason action

Fun Stuff
Check out The Name Game, Ballpark Food, Player Nicknames, and More!

Friends
Yes, we have them. Check out these other fantastic sites.

Baseball Evolution Store
Books, Baseball Cards, and Memorabilia available here