Baseball Evolution - 2006 Top 200 Composite

Rk	Player	Comp	Keith	Scott	Asher
1	Babe Ruth	1.00	1	1	1
2	Ty Cobb	2.00	2	2	2
3	Walter Johnson	3.00	3	3	3
4	Ted Williams	4.67	5	5	4
5	Rogers Hornsby	5.00	4	6	5
6	Barry Bonds	6.67	7	7	6
7	Honus Wagner	7.00	6	4	11
8	Lou Gehrig	8.67	9	10	7
9	Stan Musial	9.67	10	11	8
10	Willie Mays	9.67	11	8	10
11	Mickey Mantle	10.00	8	9	13
12	Hank Aaron	13.33	12	13	15
13	Roger Clemens	13.33	16	12	12
14	Cy Young	13.67	14	18	9
15	Tris Speaker	15.67	13	15	14
16	Eddie Collins	18.67	15	16	16
17	Mel Ott	19.33	17	19	20
18	Grover Alexander	19.33	19	21	18
19	Jimmie Foxx	20.33	22	17	19
20	Rickey Henderson	20.67	18	20	23
21	Lefty Grove	21.00	20	14	28
22	Mike Schmidt	23.33	24	22	17
23	Napoleon Lajoie	24.33	23	23	24
24	Frank Robinson	26.00	26	25	22
25	Joe Morgan	26.33	21	26	31
26	Greg Maddux	26.33	27	27	25
27	Joe DiMaggio	26.67	28	24	27
28	Christy Matthewson	29.67	30	29	21
29	Eddie Mathews	32.67	25	28	36
30	Johnny Mize	33.00	31	33	34
31	Randy Johnson	34.00	36	34	29
32	George Brett	34.33	40	32	30
33	Arky Vaughan	35.67	29	31	43
34	Alex Rodriguez	37.33	38	43	26
35	Frank Thomas	37.33	34	46	32
36	Pedro Martinez	37.67	32	38	42
37	Joe Jackson	38.33	45	30	38
38	Bill Dickey	39.00	33	42	40
39	Hank Greenberg	39.67	37	36	44
40	Jeff Bagwell	40.00	39	45	35
41	Tom Seaver	40.33	42	41	37
42	Mike Piazza	40.33	35	37	49
43	Yogi Berra	46.33	49	39	33
44	Charlie Gehringer	47.00	48	50	41
45	Johnny Bench	47.33	44	52	45
46	Sam Crawford	48.33	59	44	39
47	Jackie Robinson	48.67	52	40	53
48	Mark McGwire	49.33	41	51	54
49	Wade Boggs	50.33	43	54	51
50	Ken Griffey Jr.	54.33	57	47	47
51	Bob Feller	55.67	61	56	46
52	Reggie Jackson	56.33	62	57	48
53	Carl Hubbell	56.67	64	55	50
54	Mickey Cochrane	57.67	46	66	58
55	Willie McCovey	58.67	55	59	59
56	Tony Gwynn	59.00	71	53	52
57	Harry Heilmann	60.33	54	68	55
58	Gary Sheffield	61.33	53	65	63
59	Bob Gibson	61.67	67	61	56
60	Carl Yastrzemski	63.00	81	35	69
61	Whitey Ford	66.00	58	69	62
62	Harmon Killebrew	66.00	75	63	60
63	Paul Waner	66.67	60	74	64
64	Rod Carew	66.67	63	70	67
65	Willie Stargell	67.00	77	62	61
66	Gabby Hartnett	71.00	47	60	94
67	Al Kaline	71.33	73	67	73
68	Craig Biggio	71.67	68	71	75
69	Ed Walsh	71.67	50	73	92
70	Tim Raines	72.33	56	75	84
71	Warren Spahn	73.33	82	64	71
72	Joe Cronin	74.67	79	76	65
73	Cal Ripken	75.00	118	49	57
74	Duke Snider	76.67	86	58	81
75	Manny Ramirez	76.67	76	84	70
76	Three Finger Brown	76.67	72	82	76
77	Home Run Baker	78.00	78	78	78
78	Barry Larkin	79.67	65	81	93
79	Hoyt Wilhelm	80.00	51	86	103
80	Dick Allen	81.33	74	83	87
81	Jim Thome	82.33	80	95	72
82	Chipper Jones	82.67	66	116	66
83	Al Simmons	85.00	90	79	86
84	Pete Rose	85.67	94	72	91
85	Roberto Alomar	86.33	84	93	82
86	Dave Winfield	88.00	95	92	77
87	Ernie Banks	89.00	103	85	79
88	Robin Yount	89.33	101	77	90
89	Eddie Murray	91.00	91	80	102
90	Edgar Martinez	91.67	70	122	83
91	Eddie Plank	93.00	97	108	74
92	Luke Appling	93.33	69	102	109
93	Ralph Kiner	93.67	96	87	98
94	Ron Santo	97.67	102	91	100
95	Paul Molitor	98.67	85	123	88
96	Roger Bresnahan	98.67	83	101	112
97	Rafael Palmiero	99.33	89	104	105
98	Carlton Fisk	101.33	99	98	107
99	Jim Palmer	103.33	92	94	124
100	Rube Waddell	104.00	104	111	97
101	Ryne Sandberg	104.00	126	97	89
102	Stan Hack	105.33	87	119	110
103	Steve Carlton	105.67	148	89	80
104	Bobby Grich	106.00	98	107	113
105	Juan Marichal	106.00	151	99	68
106	Frankie Frisch	107.67	122	105	96
107	Addie Joss	108.33	112	112	101
108	Roberto Clemente	108.67	134	88	104
109	Lou Boudreau	109.33	88	113	127
110	Fred Clarke	110.67	93	96	143
111	Roy Campanella	112.33	113	129	95
112	Mariano Rivera	112.67	100	106	132
113	Minnie Minoso	114.00	125	100	117
114	Billy Williams	117.00	119	117	115
115	Gene Tenace	118.00	105	118	131
116	Sherry Magee	118.00	109	115	130
117	Lou Whitaker	121.33	106	139	119
118	Bob Johnson	125.33	107	125	144
119	Larry Doby	125.67	169	109	99
120	Bert Blyleven	126.00	116	120	142
121	Sandy Koufax	127.67	166	103	114
122	Jeff Kent	128.67	140	110	136
123	Albert Belle	129.00	135	141	111
124	Larry Walker	129.33	128	140	120
125	Curt Schilling	130.33	108	128	155
126	Nolan Ryan	131.33	198	90	106
127	Fred McGriff	132.00	143	145	108
128	Alan Trammell	133.00	137	144	118
129	Will Clark	133.67	131	136	134
130	Derek Jeter	134.00	115	148	139
131	Tom Glavine	135.00	142	127	147
132	Fergie Jenkins	138.67	NR	131	85
133	Jack Clark	139.00	130	132	156
134	Gary Carter	139.33	117	126	176
135	Reggie Smith	139.67	129	134	157
136	Joe Torre	140.00	132	138	153
137	Gaylord Perry	141.00	120	121	183
138	Al Rosen	141.33	149	124	160
139	Kevin Brown	144.33	127	137	171
140	Tony Lazzeri	145.00	144	143	149
141	Dazzy Vance	145.33	157	147	133
142	Elmer Flick	145.67	111	130	NR
143	Hack Wilson	147.33	114	162	166
144	Goose Goslin	147.33	139	152	154
145	Larry Doyle	148.33	152	158	138
146	Gavvy Cravath	149.33	NR	114	135
147	Satchel Paige	150.00	NR	48	NR
148	Mike Mussina	150.00	145	142	165
149	Ivan Rodriguez	150.67	150	163	140
150	Wally Schang	151.00	121	146	187
151	Ted Simmons	151.33	138	197	121
152	Chuck Klein	152.00	175	156	128
153	Frank Howard	153.00	164	183	116
154	Joe Gordon	154.33	168	151	145
155	Nomar Garciaparra	154.67	110	154	NR
156	Vern Stephens	155.00	154	160	151
157	Stan Coveleski	155.00	133	135	198
158	John Smoltz	155.33	141	173	158
159	Sammy Sosa	157.33	185	161	126
160	Bobby Bonds	157.33	178	166	129
161	Brooks Robinson	157.67	NR	155	125
162	Dennis Eckersley	160.33	200	133	148
163	Charlie Keller	160.33	123	NR	164
164	Joe Medwick	162.67	158	167	169
165	Bob Elliott	164.67	147	176	174
166	Bobby Doerr	165.67	182	171	146
167	Darrell Evans	166.33	153	153	193
168	Ozzie Smith	166.33	181	150	170
169	George Sisler	167.00	NR	180	122
170	Phil Niekro	167.67	155	159	191
171	Ron Cey	168.33	161	164	181
172	Ernie Lombardi	168.67	179	165	163
173	Bill Terry	169.00	170	177	161
174	Earl Averill	169.33	194	174	141
175	Jason Giambi	169.67	156	157	NR
176	Norm Cash	171.33	180	187	150
177	Billy Herman	172.33	174	189	159
178	Joe Sewell	174.00	146	194	184
179	Carlos Delgado	174.67	NR	NR	123
180	Scott Rolen	175.00	124	NR	NR
181	Eppa Rixey	175.33	160	168	NR
182	Babe Herman	176.33	162	NR	172
183	Brian Giles	178.33	183	NR	152
184	Robin Roberts	178.67	NR	149	186
185	Hal Newhouser	178.67	136	NR	NR
186	Vlad Guerrero	179.33	NR	NR	137
187	Zach Wheat	179.67	190	172	178
188	Red Faber	180.00	163	179	NR
189	Ray Schalk	181.00	167	184	197
190	Tommy Bridges	182.67	177	170	NR
191	Jim Edmonds	182.67	191	NR	162
192	Eddie Cicotte	184.67	186	169	NR
193	Ken Singleton	185.33	173	186	NR
194	Toby Harrah	186.67	159	NR	NR
195	Jimmy Wynn	187.00	184	178	NR
196	Keith Hernandez	187.67	176	188	NR
197	Ted Lyons	188.33	172	193	NR
198	Sal Bando	188.67	165	NR	NR
199	Darryl Strawberry	189.00	NR	NR	167
200	Jimmy Collins	189.67	189	190	190
201	Jose Canseco	189.67	NR	NR	168
202	Jim Fregosi	190.00	171	NR	NR
203	Frank Chance	191.00	199	175	NR
204	Ken Williams	191.67	NR	NR	173
205	Kirby Puckett	191.67	NR	NR	175
206	Trevor Hoffman	192.33	NR	182	194
207	Dan Quisenberry	192.33	NR	NR	177
208	Wally Berger	193.00	NR	NR	179
209	Juan Gonzalez	193.67	NR	NR	180
210	Don Drysdale	194.00	193	NR	189
211	Dwight Evans	194.33	NR	181	NR
212	Heinie Groh	194.33	NR	NR	182
213	Joe Tinker	194.67	187	196	NR
214	Johnny Evers	194.67	192	192	NR
215	Edd Roush	195.00	NR	185	NR
216	Pie Traynor	195.67	NR	NR	185
217	Enos Slaughter	195.67	188	NR	NR
218	Sam Rice	196.67	NR	NR	188
219	Orlando Cepeda	196.67	NR	198	192
220	Tony Perez	197.00	NR	191	NR
221	Andre Dawson	198.33	NR	195	199
222	Jim Rice	199.00	NR	NR	195
223	Spud Chandler	199.00	195	NR	NR
224	Cesar Cedeno	199.33	196	NR	NR
225	Dale Murphy	199.33	NR	NR	196
226	Bill Madlock	199.67	197	NR	NR
227	Bill Mazeroski	200.33	NR	199	NR
228	Lou Brock	200.67	NR	NR	200
229	Urban Shocker	200.67	NR	200	NR

Disagree with something? Got something to add? Wanna bring up something totally new? The staff of Baseball Evolution can be reached at comments@baseballevolution.com.