This Could Be Your Ad! Sponsor . . .
The BaseballEvolution.com 2006 Top 200 Composite!
Advertise your business, or pay tribute to your favorite team!
Rk Player Comp Keith Scott Asher
1 Babe Ruth 1.00 1 1 1
2 Ty Cobb 2.00 2 2 2
3 Walter Johnson 3.00 3 3 3
4 Ted Williams 4.67 5 5 4
5 Rogers Hornsby 5.00 4 6 5
6 Barry Bonds 6.67 7 7 6
7 Honus Wagner 7.00 6 4 11
8 Lou Gehrig 8.67 9 10 7
9 Stan Musial 9.67 10 11 8
10 Willie Mays 9.67 11 8 10
11 Mickey Mantle 10.00 8 9 13
12 Hank Aaron 13.33 12 13 15
13 Roger Clemens 13.33 16 12 12
14 Cy Young 13.67 14 18 9
15 Tris Speaker 15.67 13 15 14
16 Eddie Collins 18.67 15 16 16
17 Mel Ott 19.33 17 19 20
18 Grover Alexander 19.33 19 21 18
19 Jimmie Foxx 20.33 22 17 19
20 Rickey Henderson 20.67 18 20 23
21 Lefty Grove 21.00 20 14 28
22 Mike Schmidt 23.33 24 22 17
23 Napoleon Lajoie 24.33 23 23 24
24 Frank Robinson 26.00 26 25 22
25 Joe Morgan 26.33 21 26 31
26 Greg Maddux 26.33 27 27 25
27 Joe DiMaggio 26.67 28 24 27
28 Christy Matthewson 29.67 30 29 21
29 Eddie Mathews 32.67 25 28 36
30 Johnny Mize 33.00 31 33 34
31 Randy Johnson 34.00 36 34 29
32 George Brett 34.33 40 32 30
33 Arky Vaughan 35.67 29 31 43
34 Alex Rodriguez 37.33 38 43 26
35 Frank Thomas 37.33 34 46 32
36 Pedro Martinez 37.67 32 38 42
37 Joe Jackson 38.33 45 30 38
38 Bill Dickey 39.00 33 42 40
39 Hank Greenberg 39.67 37 36 44
40 Jeff Bagwell 40.00 39 45 35
41 Tom Seaver 40.33 42 41 37
42 Mike Piazza 40.33 35 37 49
43 Yogi Berra 46.33 49 39 33
44 Charlie Gehringer 47.00 48 50 41
45 Johnny Bench 47.33 44 52 45
46 Sam Crawford 48.33 59 44 39
47 Jackie Robinson 48.67 52 40 53
48 Mark McGwire 49.33 41 51 54
49 Wade Boggs 50.33 43 54 51
50 Ken Griffey Jr. 54.33 57 47 47
51 Bob Feller 55.67 61 56 46
52 Reggie Jackson 56.33 62 57 48
53 Carl Hubbell 56.67 64 55 50
54 Mickey Cochrane 57.67 46 66 58
55 Willie McCovey 58.67 55 59 59
56 Tony Gwynn 59.00 71 53 52
57 Harry Heilmann 60.33 54 68 55
58 Gary Sheffield 61.33 53 65 63
59 Bob Gibson 61.67 67 61 56
60 Carl Yastrzemski 63.00 81 35 69
61 Whitey Ford 66.00 58 69 62
62 Harmon Killebrew 66.00 75 63 60
63 Paul Waner 66.67 60 74 64
64 Rod Carew 66.67 63 70 67
65 Willie Stargell 67.00 77 62 61
66 Gabby Hartnett 71.00 47 60 94
67 Al Kaline 71.33 73 67 73
68 Craig Biggio 71.67 68 71 75
69 Ed Walsh 71.67 50 73 92
70 Tim Raines 72.33 56 75 84
71 Warren Spahn 73.33 82 64 71
72 Joe Cronin 74.67 79 76 65
73 Cal Ripken 75.00 118 49 57
74 Duke Snider 76.67 86 58 81
75 Manny Ramirez 76.67 76 84 70
76 Three Finger Brown 76.67 72 82 76
77 Home Run Baker 78.00 78 78 78
78 Barry Larkin 79.67 65 81 93
79 Hoyt Wilhelm 80.00 51 86 103
80 Dick Allen 81.33 74 83 87
81 Jim Thome 82.33 80 95 72
82 Chipper Jones 82.67 66 116 66
83 Al Simmons 85.00 90 79 86
84 Pete Rose 85.67 94 72 91
85 Roberto Alomar 86.33 84 93 82
86 Dave Winfield 88.00 95 92 77
87 Ernie Banks 89.00 103 85 79
88 Robin Yount 89.33 101 77 90
89 Eddie Murray 91.00 91 80 102
90 Edgar Martinez 91.67 70 122 83
91 Eddie Plank 93.00 97 108 74
92 Luke Appling 93.33 69 102 109
93 Ralph Kiner 93.67 96 87 98
94 Ron Santo 97.67 102 91 100
95 Paul Molitor 98.67 85 123 88
96 Roger Bresnahan 98.67 83 101 112
97 Rafael Palmiero 99.33 89 104 105
98 Carlton Fisk 101.33 99 98 107
99 Jim Palmer 103.33 92 94 124
100 Rube Waddell 104.00 104 111 97
101 Ryne Sandberg 104.00 126 97 89
102 Stan Hack 105.33 87 119 110
103 Steve Carlton 105.67 148 89 80
104 Bobby Grich 106.00 98 107 113
105 Juan Marichal 106.00 151 99 68
106 Frankie Frisch 107.67 122 105 96
107 Addie Joss 108.33 112 112 101
108 Roberto Clemente 108.67 134 88 104
109 Lou Boudreau 109.33 88 113 127
110 Fred Clarke 110.67 93 96 143
111 Roy Campanella 112.33 113 129 95
112 Mariano Rivera 112.67 100 106 132
113 Minnie Minoso 114.00 125 100 117
114 Billy Williams 117.00 119 117 115
115 Gene Tenace 118.00 105 118 131
116 Sherry Magee 118.00 109 115 130
117 Lou Whitaker 121.33 106 139 119
118 Bob Johnson 125.33 107 125 144
119 Larry Doby 125.67 169 109 99
120 Bert Blyleven 126.00 116 120 142
121 Sandy Koufax 127.67 166 103 114
122 Jeff Kent 128.67 140 110 136
123 Albert Belle 129.00 135 141 111
124 Larry Walker 129.33 128 140 120
125 Curt Schilling 130.33 108 128 155
126 Nolan Ryan 131.33 198 90 106
127 Fred McGriff 132.00 143 145 108
128 Alan Trammell 133.00 137 144 118
129 Will Clark 133.67 131 136 134
130 Derek Jeter 134.00 115 148 139
131 Tom Glavine 135.00 142 127 147
132 Fergie Jenkins 138.67 NR 131 85
133 Jack Clark 139.00 130 132 156
134 Gary Carter 139.33 117 126 176
135 Reggie Smith 139.67 129 134 157
136 Joe Torre 140.00 132 138 153
137 Gaylord Perry 141.00 120 121 183
138 Al Rosen 141.33 149 124 160
139 Kevin Brown 144.33 127 137 171
140 Tony Lazzeri 145.00 144 143 149
141 Dazzy Vance 145.33 157 147 133
142 Elmer Flick 145.67 111 130 NR
143 Hack Wilson 147.33 114 162 166
144 Goose Goslin 147.33 139 152 154
145 Larry Doyle 148.33 152 158 138
146 Gavvy Cravath 149.33 NR 114 135
147 Satchel Paige 150.00 NR 48 NR
148 Mike Mussina 150.00 145 142 165
149 Ivan Rodriguez 150.67 150 163 140
150 Wally Schang 151.00 121 146 187
151 Ted Simmons 151.33 138 197 121
152 Chuck Klein 152.00 175 156 128
153 Frank Howard 153.00 164 183 116
154 Joe Gordon 154.33 168 151 145
155 Nomar Garciaparra 154.67 110 154 NR
156 Vern Stephens 155.00 154 160 151
157 Stan Coveleski 155.00 133 135 198
158 John Smoltz 155.33 141 173 158
159 Sammy Sosa 157.33 185 161 126
160 Bobby Bonds 157.33 178 166 129
161 Brooks Robinson 157.67 NR 155 125
162 Dennis Eckersley 160.33 200 133 148
163 Charlie Keller 160.33 123 NR 164
164 Joe Medwick 162.67 158 167 169
165 Bob Elliott 164.67 147 176 174
166 Bobby Doerr 165.67 182 171 146
167 Darrell Evans 166.33 153 153 193
168 Ozzie Smith 166.33 181 150 170
169 George Sisler 167.00 NR 180 122
170 Phil Niekro 167.67 155 159 191
171 Ron Cey 168.33 161 164 181
172 Ernie Lombardi 168.67 179 165 163
173 Bill Terry 169.00 170 177 161
174 Earl Averill 169.33 194 174 141
175 Jason Giambi 169.67 156 157 NR
176 Norm Cash 171.33 180 187 150
177 Billy Herman 172.33 174 189 159
178 Joe Sewell 174.00 146 194 184
179 Carlos Delgado 174.67 NR NR 123
180 Scott Rolen 175.00 124 NR NR
181 Eppa Rixey 175.33 160 168 NR
182 Babe Herman 176.33 162 NR 172
183 Brian Giles 178.33 183 NR 152
184 Robin Roberts 178.67 NR 149 186
185 Hal Newhouser 178.67 136 NR NR
186 Vlad Guerrero 179.33 NR NR 137
187 Zach Wheat 179.67 190 172 178
188 Red Faber 180.00 163 179 NR
189 Ray Schalk 181.00 167 184 197
190 Tommy Bridges 182.67 177 170 NR
191 Jim Edmonds 182.67 191 NR 162
192 Eddie Cicotte 184.67 186 169 NR
193 Ken Singleton 185.33 173 186 NR
194 Toby Harrah 186.67 159 NR NR
195 Jimmy Wynn 187.00 184 178 NR
196 Keith Hernandez 187.67 176 188 NR
197 Ted Lyons 188.33 172 193 NR
198 Sal Bando 188.67 165 NR NR
199 Darryl Strawberry 189.00 NR NR 167
200 Jimmy Collins 189.67 189 190 190
201 Jose Canseco 189.67 NR NR 168
202 Jim Fregosi 190.00 171 NR NR
203 Frank Chance 191.00 199 175 NR
204 Ken Williams 191.67 NR NR 173
205 Kirby Puckett 191.67 NR NR 175
206 Trevor Hoffman 192.33 NR 182 194
207 Dan Quisenberry 192.33 NR NR 177
208 Wally Berger 193.00 NR NR 179
209 Juan Gonzalez 193.67 NR NR 180
210 Don Drysdale 194.00 193 NR 189
211 Dwight Evans 194.33 NR 181 NR
212 Heinie Groh 194.33 NR NR 182
213 Joe Tinker 194.67 187 196 NR
214 Johnny Evers 194.67 192 192 NR
215 Edd Roush 195.00 NR 185 NR
216 Pie Traynor 195.67 NR NR 185
217 Enos Slaughter 195.67 188 NR NR
218 Sam Rice 196.67 NR NR 188
219 Orlando Cepeda 196.67 NR 198 192
220 Tony Perez 197.00 NR 191 NR
221 Andre Dawson 198.33 NR 195 199
222 Jim Rice 199.00 NR NR 195
223 Spud Chandler 199.00 195 NR NR
224 Cesar Cedeno 199.33 196 NR NR
225 Dale Murphy 199.33 NR NR 196
226 Bill Madlock 199.67 197 NR NR
227 Bill Mazeroski 200.33 NR 199 NR
228 Lou Brock 200.67 NR NR 200
229 Urban Shocker 200.67 NR 200 NR


Disagree with something? Got something to add? Wanna bring up something totally new? The staff of Baseball Evolution can be reached at comments@baseballevolution.com.



 GO
BaseballEvolution Features



2006 Team Previews
See where we think the teams will finish, and what we have to say about them

Hall of Fame
See who's in, who's out, and where we differ from Cooperstown

The Teams Page
Find about all about your favorite team including Stats Leaders, Awards, Playoff Teams, and More.

Splitsville
Join us as we sift through all kinds of split statistics and divulge what they mean (if anything)

Statistics
Your source for stats, both conventional and otherwise.

Award Room
MVPs, Cy Youngs, Gonzalez's and Kingmans - all of your award info and analysis right here.

Top 100s
See where we rank'em, and how our lists compare to Bill James, Total Baseball, and others.
Trivia
Test your baseball knowledge with our obscure knowledge quizzes!

Predictions
As the season rolls along, check to see how accurate our 2005 predictions were.

Boneheads
See who's making a lot of money to embarrass themselves writing about baseball.

Heated Debates
We don't always agree with each other. In fact, we often don't!

Scorer's Corner
Join Keith in his Scorer's Corner as he shares scoring oddities that he has encountered while scoring Zephyr games.

Scouting Reports
In-depth analysis of various high-level prospects around baseball

Playoff Central
Previews and analysis of all of the exciting postseason action

Fun Stuff
Check out The Name Game, Ballpark Food, Player Nicknames, and More!

Friends
Yes, we have them. Check out these other fantastic sites.

Baseball Evolution Store
Books, Baseball Cards, and Memorabilia available here