Visit Our Newest Feature! - The Teams Page
Find about all about your favorite team including Stats Leaders, Awards, Playoff Teams, and More . . .

The First Ever Baseball Evolution Hall of Fame Ballot

Rules: Only eligible players and managers allowed. Scott, Keith, and Asher will each assign a point value of either 2 (sure thing), 1 (worth considering), or 0 (heck no) to every player on this ballot. Once totalled:

Candidates who garner 5 or 6 votes are elected into the Hall

Candidates receiving 3 or 4 votes remain on next year’s balot

Candidates cajoling fewer than 3 votes are off the list

A candidate may only re-enter the ballot through unanimous nomination.

And now... The Candidates:



Goose Gossage

Rocky Colavito

Addie Joss

Graig Nettles

Rod Carew

Al Kaline

Hack Wilson

Roger Bresnahan

Al Rosen

Hal Newhouser

Roger Connor

Al Simmons

Hank Aaron

Roger Maris

Alan Trammel

Hank Greenberg

Rogers Hornsby

Albert Belle

Hardy Richardson

Rollie Fingers

Amos Rusie

Harmon Killebrew

Ron Cey

Andre Dawson

Harry Breechen

Ron Guidry

Arky Vaughan

Harry Heilmann

Ron Santo

Babe Adams

Harry Hooper

Ross Barnes

Babe Herman

Harry Stovey

Ross Youngs

Babe Ruth

Harvey Kuenn

Roy Campanella

Bert Blyleven

Clark Griffith

Roy Thomas

Bid McPhee

Heinie Groh

Rube Marquard

Bill Dahlen

Heinie Manush

Rube Waddell

Bill Dickey

Heinie Zimmerman

Rusty Staub

Bill Madlock

Herb Pennock

Ryne Sandberg

Bill Mazeroski

Honus Wagner

Sal Bando

Bill Nicholson

Hoyt Wilhelm

Sal Maglie

Bill Terry

Hugh Duffy

Sam Crawford

Billy Hamilton

Hughie Jennings

Sam Leever

Billy Herman

Jack Chesbro

Sam Rice

Billy Pierce

Jack Clark

Sam Thompson

Billy Williams

Jack Fournier

Sandy Koufax

Bo Jackson

Jack Morris

Satchel Paige

Bob Caruthers

Jackie Robinson

Sherry Magee

Bob Elliot

Jake Beckley

Sid Gordon

Bob Feller

Jeff Heath

Silver King

Bob Gibson

Jesse Burkett

Smokey Joe Wood

Bob Johnson

Jesse Haines

Sparky Lyle

Bob Lemon

Jim Bottomley

Spud Chandler

Bobby Bonds

Jim Bunning

Stan Coveleski

Bobby Doerr

Jim Fregosi

Stan Hack

Bobby Grich

Jim Kaat

Stan Musial

Bobby Wallace

Jim McCormick

Steve Carlton

Boog Powell

Jim O'Rourke

Steve Garvey

Brett Saberhagen

Jim Palmer

Ted Kluszewski

Brooks Robinson

Jim Rice

Ted Lyons

Buck Ewing

Jimmie Foxx

Ted Simmons

Bucky Walters

Jimmy Collins

Ted Williams

Burleigh Grimes

Jimmy Key

Thurman Munson

Cap Anson

Jimmy Ryan

Tim Keefe

Carl Hubbell

Jimmy Wynn

Toby Harrah

Carl Mays

Joe Cronin

Tom Henke

Carl Yastrzemski

Joe DiMaggio

Tom Seaver

Carlton Fisk

Joe Gordon

Tommy Bridges

Catfish Hunter

Joe Kelley

Tommy John

Cesar Cedeno

Joe McGinnity

Tommy McCarthy

Charley Radbourn

Joe Medwick

Tony Lazzeri

Charlie Gehringer

Joe Morgan

Tony Mullane

Charlie Keller

Joe Sewell

Tony Mullane

Chick Hafey

Joe Tinker

Tony Oliva

Chief Bender

Joe Torre

Tony Perez

Christy Mathewson

John Clarkson

Topsy Hartsel

Chuck Klein

John Hiller

Travis Jackson

Cy Williams

John Ward

Tris Speaker

Cy Young

Johnny Bench

Ty Cobb

Dale Murphy

Johnny Evers

Urban Schocker

Dan Brouthers

Johnny Mize

Vern Stephens

Dan Quisenberry

Johnny Pesky

Vic Willis

Darrell Evans

Juan Marichal

Wade Boggs

Darryl Strawberry

Keith Hernandez

Waite Hoyt

Dave Bancroft

Ken Singleton

Wally Berger

Dave Concepcion

Ken Tekulve

Wally  Schang

Dave Foutz

Kid Nichols

Walter Johnson

Dave Kingman

Kiki Cuyler

Warren Spahn

Dave Parker

King Kelly

Whitey Ford

Dave Stieb

Kirby Puckett

Wilbur Cooper

Dave Winfield

Lance Parrish

Will Clark

Dazzy Vance

Larry Doby

Will White

Deacon White

Larry Doyle

Willie Keeler

Dennis Eckersley

Lee Smith

Willie Mays

Dick  Allen

Lefty Gomez

Willie McCovey

Dizzy Dean

Lefty Grove

Willie McGee

Dizzy Trout

Lefty O'Doul

Willie Randolph

Dolph Camilli

Lloyd Waner

Willie Stargell

Don Drysdale

Lon Warneke

Yogi Berra

Don Mattingly

Lou Boudreau

Zack Wheat

Don Sutton

Lou Brock

George Wright

Duke Snider

Lou Gehrig

Al Spalding

Dutch E Leonard

Lou Whitaker

Candy Cummings

Dwight Evans

Luis Aparicio

Dwight Gooden

Luis Tiant

Negro Leaguers

Earl Averill

Luke Appling

Martin Dihigo

Earle Combs

Max Carey

Pop Lloyd

Early Wynn

Mel Ott

Oscar Charleston

Ed Delahanty

Mickey Cochrane

Judy Johnson

Ed Walsh

Mickey Mantle

Cool Papa Bell

Edd Roush

Mickey Welch

Monte Irvin

Eddie Collins

Mike Marshall (pitcher)

Josh Gibson

Eddie Mathews

Mike Schmidt

Buck Leonard

Eddie Murray

Mike Tiernan

Bill Foster

Eddie Plank

Minnie Minoso

Bullet Rogan

Eddie Yost

Mordecai Brown

Hilton Smith

Elmer Flick

Nap Lajoie

Joe Williams

Enos Slaughter

Nellie Fox

Leon Day

Eppa Rixey

Nolan Ryan

Ray Dandridge

Eric Davis

Norm Cash

Willie Wells

Ernie Banks

Orel Hershiser

Turkey Stearnes

Ernie Lombardi

Orlando Cepeda

Fergie Jenkins

Ozzie Guillen


Frank Baker

Ozzie Smith

Al Lopez

Frank Chance

Paul Hines

Bill McKechnie

Frank Howard

Paul Molitor

Billy Martin

Frank Robinson

Paul Waner

Billy Southworth

Frankie Frisch

Pedro Guerrero

Bucky Harris

Fred Clarke

Pee Wee Reese

Casey Stengel

Fred Dunlap

Pete Alexander

Charlie Grimm

Fred Lynn

Pete Browning

Connie Mack

Freddie Lindstrom

Phil Niekro

Danny Murtaugh

Gabby Hartnett

Phil Rizzuto

Davey Johnson

Gary Carter

Pie Traynor

Dick Williams

Gary Gaetti

Pud Galvin

Earl Weaver

Gavvy Cravath

Rabbit Maranville

Frank Selee

Gaylord Perry

Ralph Kiner

Gene Mauch

Gene Tenace

Ray Schalk

Joe McCarthy

George Brett

Red Faber

John McGraw

George Burns

Red Ruffing

Leo Durocher

George Burns

Red Schoendienst

Miller Huggins

George Davis

Reggie Jackson

Ned Hanlon

George Foster

Reggie Smith

Ralph Houk

George Kell

Richie Ashburn

Rube Foster

George Kelly

Rick Ferrell

Sparky Anderson

George Sisler

Rico Carty

Tommy Lasorda

George Van Haltern

Roberto Clemente

Walter Alston

Gil Hodges

Robin Roberts

Whitey Herzog

Goose Goslin

Robin Yount

Wilbert Robinson Harry Wright
Charlie Commiskey

Got something to say with regards to either the Cooperstown or Baseball Evolution Hall of Fame? Contact us at

Baseball Evolution Features

The Teams Page
Find about all about your favorite team.

All kinds of split statistics and what they mean.

Your source for stats, conventional and otherwise.

Award Room
All of your award info and analysis right here.

News and Notes
Interesting odds and ends from around the league.

Top 100s
See where we rank'em.

Test your baseball knowledge.

As the season rolls along, check to see how accurate our 2005 predictions were.

See who's making a lot of money to embarrass themselves writing about baseball.

Heated Debates
We don't always agree with each other.

Scorer's Corner
Keith shares scoring oddities that he has encountered.

Player Nicknames
How we refer to certain players when we're discussing them.

Ballpark Food
What various ballparks around the league should be serving up to the fans.

Scouting Reports
In-depth analysis of high-level prospects.

The Name Game
Put your skills to the test.